Case Studies

A Collection of the Odd, Unusual and Interesting Found While Servicing Our Client Vehicles.

Originally intended as a showcase for customers of our workshop and staff’s abilities, this page has evolved in an interesting and informative teaching tool, and one of the most popular pages on our site!

By nature, these are rather extreme examples of failures, and not what we typically find during service. Our goal at Atlantic Motorcar is to prevent these from happening to you and your car. But rest assured, if we can fix these challenges, regular maintenance is breeze!

We like to call this our “YES WE CAN!” page. You can also view many of these concerns on our Facebook page. Each photo can be enlarged by clicking on it.

Tech Tip – The Truth About Lifetime Transmission Fluids – “Oil is Cheaper Than Metal”

Case Studies
BMW, Mini Cooper Transmission Fluid

There is a trend with many manufacturers to use so called “Lifetime” transmission fluids in their new cars. Audi, BMW and Mercedes have been doing this for years.

The real question is what is a “lifetime”? If the lifetime of the car is the reference point, most owners will be sorely disappointed, for it seems to us that almost all of the fluids need service around 60K miles, far shorter than the lifetime of most European cars. While fluids and lubricants have doubtlessly improved over time, we suspect that the real reason for these “lifetime” fluids is the extended service intervals of new cars.

Often times the manufacturer will offer “free” service for the first 60K or so miles. So the “lifetime” fluid is just one way for them to lower their costs, you just pay the tab later. Doesn’t sound fair, does it? We agree.

The “Free Service” program is great for the first 60,000 miles. The original owner will rave about the low maintenance car where he received 3 or so free oil changes & perhaps a brake service.

A happy owner drives Consumer Satisfaction Scores up, more new cars are then sold, and the manufacturer is very pleased. Problem is, the next 60,000 miles. If the original owner keeps the car reality will set in pretty quickly, or worse, the car is sold, and now the new owner starts to pay the piper for the deferred service.

BMW, Mini Cooper Transmission Fluid

Over the last 10 years as we’ve noted the trend toward reduced or eliminated fluid services, we’ve also noted a corresponding increase in transmission and driveline problems.

We have an expression here, “Oil is cheaper than metal.”, it is much less expensive to change fluids, even the synthetic fluids, than it is to replace parts.

With full fluid service on a newer BMW or Volvo is in the $350 – $400 range, a transmission is in the $5,000+ range, its an easy decision to make!

We service a great many new cars still in warranty, but we also have some higher milage units still going strong on 300,000 miles, so we know that fluid service, and preventive maintenance does work.

We delight in taking folks into our shop to show them exactly what we’ve found. The more you know about your car, the better you can work with the folks helping you.

Thanks,
AMC Service Team

Read More

BMW and Mini Cooper Battery Replacement – Registering New Battery

Case Studies

Did you know that the BMW engine computer, known as a DME (Digital Motor Electronics) must be programed to know a new battery has been installed?

Our Senior Service Technician Nick explains why. We’re obviously playing up the humor here, but the topic isn’t a joke, it’s a real issue.

Otherwise the battery can under or overcharge, and cause premature battery failure. Older batteries become sulfated with time and require a higher charging rate. So unless the DME is notified a new battery is installed, it will often overcharge, and damage the new battery in short order.

 

The #1 reason for battery failure after battery replacement, other than the use of the incorrect battery type, is the failure to properly program the car.

Knowledge, Integrity, Trust. Every time.
Because you and your car deserve it!

– Bruce

Read More

BMW Engine Camshaft Bolts Problem – Repair and Correction

Case Studies

What Happens
Certain late model BMWs can experience a problem with the camshaft sprocket retention bolts failing.
This is a design defect, and well know in professional BMW service circles.
You can see on the photo below, that VANOS (variable valve timing system) to intake camshaft bolts have broken and backed out, 3 of the 4 bolts are damaged and loose.

BMW said “in very rare cases the bolts holding the variable camshaft timing (Vanos) unit housing may become loose or, in extreme cases, break.” In such cases, the driver would be alerted by a check-engine warning light. Power to the engine could be reduced and “if ignored, the problem can become progressively worse, eventually leading to no-start conditions, stalling and engine damage.” Vanos is BMW’s variable-valve timing technology.

The models affected by the recall are the 1 Series, 3 Series, 5 Series, 5 Series Gran Turismo, X3, X5, X6 and Z4 from the 2010-12 model years, as well as the 2012 6 Series.

Why Bad
It is important to correct this ASAP as it will allow camshaft to become unsynchronized with the crankshaft, pistons will strike valves and do massive internal engine damage. Or a bolt backs out and falls into the timing change, Either way, a very bad day.

Cause Of Failure
Signs and Symptoms of this problem include VANOS fault codes, rough idle, engine noise, knocking or clicking sound, maybe a rumbling noise. Then, if not corrected, the KABOOM. An expensive “KABOOM”.

If you experience any of the following signs, you may be on your way to bolt failure.
Call or stop by the Atlantic Motorcar Center so we can check out your BMW immediately.

  • Your check engine light comes on
  • You hear a knocking noise that sounds like metal on metal
  • You experience a great loss of power

Prevention
The old bromide that “An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure” never rang truer than in the case of your engine’s internals. Proper servicing, which is all too often overlooked on today’s newer cars with their extended service intervals, will go a long way to preventing problems in the first place.

We strongly advise to all of our BMW and Mini Cooper customers, to consider changing the engine oil and filter every 5,000 miles. Following extended service intervals of 12,000 to 15,000 miles is a recipe for failure, setting the customer up for a very expensive, and very unexpected failure down the road. Nothing is less costly, or can do more to prolong the life of your car, than changing the fluid and filter (if equipped) on a regular basis, BEFORE failure.

Your Advocate, On Your Side
At AMC, because we are independent and locally owned, we are YOUR advocate, and our team makes a point of checking recalls and service campaigns from the manufacturer on every visit, and keeping our customers up to date.

Final
Not a simple repair, yes, but one, if done correctly, will last several years. That’s our goal with BMW, and other autos here, fix it right the first time, and prevent problems from happening in the first place. 30 years of service experience have well taught us that “an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.”

Be cured, once and for all, and give us a call, we’re happy to answer any service questions you might have on your BMW, Audi, Mercedes, Lexus, Volvo or Volkswagen.Earning your trust, every time you turn the car…that’s what we do…every day…for the last 30 years. Click here see what our happy customers have to say about us and our service at AMC Customer Reviews.

If you have questions, or if we can be of further assistance, just call us at (207) 882-969, we’d love to meet you, and your car!

Warmly,
Bruce and the AMC Service Team

Read More

Volvo Differential Rebuilding Service – Out of Our Area? Send Your Unit To Us

Case Studies

The Problem
The rear differential design has been in use in the Volvo world since the 2008 to at least the 2014 model year, so it’s something to consider if you own a vehicle in that range. We service a tremendous amount of Volvo XC70s, and have seen the problem largely on those models, but have read reports of it being an issue on the S80 as well. Now the earlier Volvos had their own set of differential or bevel gear problems, which you can read about on our blog at Volvo AOC problems.

What We Do
We mentioned that we’ve seen this problem before, and we’ve also seen the new car dealer quotes for the repair, costing anywhere from $6,000 to $8,000 dollars. Sounds expensive, right? Well the part itself is $4,200 from Volvo, not factoring in the considerable labor remove the defective unit, and install the new. The other option, a used part, was considered an unacceptable choice as this is a pattern failure, a common issue with many of the cars, and if the used one was not already in a later stage of failure, the installed price tag, over $4,800 to $5,500 with no real warranty, is not a good solution.

Outside Our Area? – Send Your Unit To Our Experts
No problem, just have your local shop remove the differential, then have them drain and flush out the fluids well for shipping. Package the unit well, your local UPS store can do this for you with a “foam in place” box, remember the box needs to keep the unit safe on the way here and the way back to you.

Our cost to rebuild with a durable solution, Atlantic Motorcar easily save you $3,000 over the dealer price, we can do the complete repair, with a 1 year National Warranty, and since we’re only doing the rebuilding, the cost is about $2,900 to $3,200. Yes, really. Turnaround time is about 1 to 2 days. Call us for details at (207) 882-9969.

Failed Bearing

Repair, Not Replace
Sadly the concept of repair, or rebuilding something rather than just replacing it, has become nearly a lost art in today’s automotive world. The concept of diagnosing and understanding the nature of the failure, then effecting a targeted repair to the system, seems to be past history. One thing that we pride in here at AMC, is our ability to diagnose, first understand why the problem occurred – understanding the “why” is the key to preventing a reoccurrence, and then designing a durable solution to the problem. By durable, we mean minimally giving the service life of the replaced part, ideally longer.

The concept of disassembling and rebuilding a mechanism like a Haldex differential is not common today, but here’s where Atlantic Motorcar shines. We actually employ skilled technicians who are craftsman, they have not only the ability, but are encouraged to repair, rather than just replace. In this case, our tech removed failed differential from the vehicle, disassembled and inspected to identify the failure, and then assessed what components were needed to rebuild the unit for a durable repair, lasting ideally the life of the car. And this just what we did, and we can do the same thing for you, if you have this problem with your Volvo or Land Rover.

Volvo Magic Fluid

Once Of Prevention, Worth A Pound Of Cure

Unfortunately, the Volvo differential is equipped with “fill for life” fluid. In the marketing parlance of the day, this is touted as a benefit, and yet at 90,000 miles this part has failed. Would changing the fluid more frequently have saved this part? Very we say likely yes; however fluid changes are often left out of the service schedule by the manufacturer on the newer cars to save money. After all, the manufacturers are in the business of selling new cars, not necessarily maintaining old ones.

Fluid changes on this system are not a “do it yourself” thing, as there is no real provision to drain out the old fluid, it must instead be aspirated, or sucked out with fluid transfer equipment, and the housing cleaned carefully to remove any metal or wear debris. Fortunately Atlantic Motorcar is very well equipped in this regard, and we strongly advise adding a differential fluid service on Volvos at the 90,000 mile service interval, if not sooner.

About that magic fluid. Volvos sell a very expensive, and specialty branded ‘special lubricant’ for their power transfer unit or angle gear unit, yet these components only consist of simple gears and bearings. Rather than the costly, and apparently insufficient factory fill, we always use synthetic gear oil just to add a little extra margin of durability. This still costs a fraction of the dealer fluid. It is important to use the manufacturers recommended fluid while the vehicle is under the new car warranty.

How We Can Help
At Atlantic Motorcar we’ve developed some very specific procedures and tooling, combined with our expect technicians, to make this otherwise onerous repair a snap. Well, maybe not a “snap”, hard to call a day + of labor a snap, let’s just say that we make it flow very, very smoothly. All told, proper maintenance and repair is far less costly than replacing your vehicle every 3 year or so.

Finally
Questions, or if we can be of help in any way with service on your Audi, BMW, Mercedes, Mini Cooper or other European (and now Japanese) import, please contact us. Our team of Service Specialists are here to help, for even the newest autos! (207) 882-9969.

Knowing, not just “doing”, that’s the Atlantic Motorcar Center way of life.
Thanks!

Warmly,
The Atlantic Motorcar Center Service Team

Read More

Sometimes, It’s More Than Just Cars

Case Studies
Joe and our new Friend

I Met A Hero Today
My client with the vintage 1988 Mercedes project car we’ve been working on for the last month.

A humble man, he’s currently 95 years old, joined the British RAF (Royal Air Force) at age 16, flew a Lancaster bomber against the Nazis at age 17 in the Second World War. Then after the war flew in support of the Berlin airlift, flying in supplies to the starving residents of West Berlin.

He shared that he met Winston Churchill twice (Churchill remembered him on the second meeting), and recalled that Churchill handed out cigars to his entire squadron, insisting on smoking with them.

He dearly loves his car, having owned it since it was almost new, and plans to drive it another 5 years, until he’s 100. Such was the complexity of the service issues, he had all but given up hope of driving it again. It was our pleasure to make that happen.

The vehicle had a history of low power, stalling, not starting, which we diagnosed and corrected. Not too many people around that understand KE Jet, I’m starting to feel old. 🙂 I started my automotive service career in 1985, so 32 years later, this still feels like a new car to me.

Every member of my team who had a part in the resurrection of his beloved auto was there. Our parts manager Jared who sourced parts for a 30 year classic, our service tech who worked alongside of me on the vehicle over the last month, and our detailer Joe (also a veteran) who make it shine like new. Joe is in the photo with him.

Presenting his vehicle back to him, now purring like a kitten, fully serviced, detailed, waxed and polished was one of the proudest moments of my career, and I think for the rest of my team.

Of all the projects I worked on this year, this one was both a privilege and a pleasure, even more so now I know how deeply our efforts were appreciated. We not only earned a new customer, but a very special new friend.

– Bruce

 

Back Story – Vintage Mercedes Project – Cold War Warrior

Just one year before the Berlin war fell, this Mercedes rolled new out of the factory.

The vintage Mercedes project car is on the road tonight, Jared, one of our Service Advisors is doing the overnight road test.

Just one year before the Berlin war fell, this Mercedes rolled new out of the factory. I’m a Cold War fan, student and history buff, having grown up in that era, so this project had a special meaning to me, one of the last Mercedes to roll out when “West Germany” was still a country.

Everything is done except for the engine oil leak reseal, will be doing that tomorrow. I wanted to get an extended road test in with the fuel injection system working correctly, and the transmission resealed.

The fuel injection system on this vehicle, a Bosch KE Jetronic, first debuted in the mid 1970s (though Mercedes used it until the late 1990s), had been a source of trouble for the previous servicing shop, and thorn in the owners side for some time. The vehicle had a history of low power, stalling, not starting, which we diagnosed and corrected. Indeed the vehicle was towed in not starting or running.

Few people still around understand Bosch KE Jet fuel injection system, I’m starting to feel old. 🙂
I started my automotive service career in 1985, so 32 years later, this still feels like a new car to me.

I personally drove it just a few minutes ago for the initial road test after the transmission work, runs and drives great, tires are noisy and ride rough, but there is some tread left on them, next year we’ll get a good set of Michelin tires on the car.

I’m VERY happy with how the car the car has turned out so far, I believe the lingering demons of starting and running have now been corrected, and the car is performing as it should. Working with owners who are deeply passionate about doing it right, and patient at the same time, has been a blessing.

I’ll check her again tomorrow morning, and baring anything else will be turning it over to Joe to do his detail magic on Monday or Tuesday.

Though we work on even the newest Mercedes, it’s always treat for me to be involved in the service of one of these icons of another, more simpler time.

Warmly,
– Bruce

Read More

Classic Mercedes Case Study – Happy Ending!

Case Studies
On Road Test

Vintage Mercedes Project – Cold War Warrior

The vintage Mercedes project car is on the road tonight, Jared, one of our Service Advisors is doing the overnight road test.

Just one year before the Berlin war fell, this Mercedes rolled new out of the factory. I’m a Cold War fan, student and history buff, having grown up in that era, so this project had a special meaning to me, one of the last Mercedes to roll out when “West Germany” was still a country.

Everything is done except for the engine oil leak reseal, will be doing that tomorrow. I wanted to get an extended road test in with the fuel injection system working correctly, and the transmission resealed.

The fuel injection system on this vehicle, a Bosch KE Jetronic, first debuted in the mid 1970s (though Mercedes used it until the late 1990s), had been a source of trouble for the previous servicing shop, and thorn in the owners side for some time. The vehicle had a history of low power, stalling, not starting, which we diagnosed and corrected. Indeed the vehicle was towed in not starting or running.

Few people still around understand Bosch KE Jet fuel injection system, I’m starting to feel old.
 I started my automotive service career in 1985, so 32 years later, this still feels like a new car to me.

I personally drove it just a few minutes ago for the initial road test after the transmission work, runs and drives great, tires are noisy and ride rough, but there is some tread left on them, next year we’ll get a good set of Michelin tires on the car.

I’m VERY happy with how the car the car has turned out so far, I believe the lingering demons of starting and running have now been corrected, and the car is performing as it should. Working with owners who are deeply passionate about doing it right, and patient at the same time, has been a blessing.

I’ll check her again tomorrow morning, and baring anything else will be turning it over to Joe to do his detail magic on Monday or Tuesday.

Though we work on even the newest Mercedes, it’s always treat for me to be involved in the service of one of these icons of another, more simpler time.

Warmly,
– Bruce

Read More

AMC Tech Tip – Low Tire Pressure Warning Lights In Cold Weather

Case Studies

AMC Tech Tip – Low Tire Pressure Warning Lights In Cold Weather

What
As winter approaches, many motorists will experience a low-pressure warning light on the dash or simply observe that the tires look a bit less full than they should. The main reason for this is the dropping temperatures, which cause the air to become denser and consequently lower the tire pressure. Of course, tires naturally lose pressure over time, or there can be a puncture.

Why
Tire pressure monitoring systems (TPMS) are a real boon to safety and convenience, and they have been required on all new cars since September 2007. By triggering a dashboard light to let you know when one or more tires is low on air, TPMS can take the guesswork out of wondering whether a tire is low. Some systems can even tell you which tire has the problem.

How
Colder temperatures will cause tire pressure to drop about 1 psi for every 10°F drop in air temperature. Getting a tire pressure warning light on a chilly morning doesn’t necessarily indicate a puncture, just that your tires are running low pressure and you need to top them off as soon as possible. Drive a few miles and the tires will warm up, perhaps causing the warning light to turn off.

Whether it goes off or not, your tire pressure needs to be checked with a gauge and topped off. This is a simple DIY chore, or stop by AMC and we’ll do it for free.

Suggestion
As a general rule, check the pressure monthly. Don’t wait for the tire pressure warning light from to come on. It’s meant to alert you of a tire losing air while you’re driving, not serve as a maintenance reminder.

Even if your vehicle is equipped with TPMS, our recommendation is to use a gauge to check the pressure in all of your tires at least once per month, no matter what the weather is like.

– Bruce

Read More

Vintage Mercedes Project – Or Reviving A Cold War Warrior

Case Studies

Vintage Mercedes Project – Cold War Warrior

Mercedes 300TE
Mercedes 300TE

The vintage Mercedes project car is on the road tonight, Jared, one of our Service Advisors is doing the overnight road test.

Just one year before the Berlin war fell, this Mercedes rolled new out of the factory. I’m a Cold War fan, student and history buff, having grown up in that era, so this project had a special meaning to me, one of the last Mercedes to roll out when “West Germany” was still a country.

Everything is done except for the engine oil leak reseal, will be doing that tomorrow. I wanted to get an extended road test in with the fuel injection system working correctly, and the transmission resealed.

The fuel injection system on this vehicle, a Bosch KE Jetronic, first debuted in the mid 1970s (though Mercedes used it until the late 1990s), had been a source of trouble for the previous servicing shop, and thorn in the owners side for some time. The vehicle had a history of low power, stalling, not starting, which we diagnosed and corrected. Indeed the vehicle was towed in not starting or running.

Few people still around understand KE Jet fuel system, I’m starting to feel old. I started my automotive service career in 1985, so 32 years later, this still feels like a new car to me.

I personally drove it just a few minutes ago for the initial road test after the transmission work, runs and drives great, tires are noisy and ride rough, but there is some tread left on them, next year we’ll get a good set of Michelin tires on the car.

I’m VERY happy with how the car the car has turned out so far, I believe the lingering demons of starting and running have now been corrected, and the car is performing as it should. Working with owners who are deeply passionate about doing it right, and patient at the same time, has been a blessing.

I’ll check her again tomorrow morning, and baring anything else will be turning it over to Joe to do his detail magic on Monday or Tuesday.

Though we work on even the newest Mercedes, it’s always treat for me to be involved in the service of one of these icons of another, more simpler time.

Warmly,
– Bruce

— at Atlantic Motorcar Center.

 

 

Read More

AMC Service Tip – Replacing Stuck or Blind Hole Bearing Races

Case Studies

Problem

Removing Stuck Bearing Races
Removing Stuck Bearing Races

Tapered roller bearings are commonly found in wheel bearings, transmission, differentials, and other automotive systems. They consist of two parts, the bearing cone with the roller bearing, and a “race”, which is the highly polished and hardened surface on which the bearing rides. The race is pressed into the part or casting and the roller bearing installed on top of it.

So let’s say you have a bearing race (transmission, wheel, differential or other) in a “blind” hole that you need to replace. By “blind” we mean you can’t access it from the back of the race, or there is no “lip” to catch to the drive out the race with the traditional brass drift and hammer. Or the race is “stuck” and you risk damaging the part itself by attempting to hammer it out, the races being a hardened material, like these Mercedes wheel bearing races in the photo below. Some shops don’t bother changing these because they are very difficult to drive out of the wheel hub without damage. This is not a good thing because the new bearings will wear out prematurely if they are installed on worn or damages races.

Solution 
Put away that hammer, and break out the MIG welder. You carefully MIG weld a circular bead on the race surface itself. As the weld cools, the bearing race shrinks because of the weld contracting the metal, and the race falls out of the part. No damage to the part from punch or chisel. It’s like magic of thermodynamics, with some help with the Atlantic Motorcar Center. 😉

Removing Stuck Bearing Races
Removing Stuck Bearing Races
Read More

Investing In Your Team – BMW Service Training

Case Studies
Investing In Your Team - BMW Training - Last Weekend
Investing In Your Team – BMW Training – Last Weekend
Want to most sincerely thank to the awesome AMC Team for attending BMW Service Training last weekend. I know that giving up a weekend isn’t what everyone looks forward to.

Ongoing training is something that we very strongly believe in here at AMC, it’s been a key corporate value since we first started in business over 30 years ago. It benefits you the customer as it assures that we always have the latest and greatest in knowledge, and service techniques, to service your car promptly and efficiently.

It’s also a way of investing in our team, a affirmation that we value, respect and want to help them grow personally and professionally. We consider that a responsibility of business, to our employees and the community.

A dedicated Training program like ours is sadly not that common in our profession. Nor it it cheap. By the time we’re done, those two days will have cost AMC well over $4,000. And we repeat that throughout the year. But we think that is a small price to always do the best for our customers, and our employees. Investing in people, on both sides of the service counter, we think that is priceless.

Next time you’re in, if you get a chance, say “Thanks” to the team, they are most dedicated group of folks I’ve ever been privileged to work with.

Warmly,
Bruce

Read More

Accessibility Toolbar